found someone posting old pictures from the website/forum dumpstersl*ts.com from back in the day
https://dumpster-sl*ts.tumblr.com/
It closed down years ago but one of the big hits of the forum was ugly chicks, and this guy seems to have a good collection. I messaged the guy and he said he has posts queued up for the rest of the year and beyond so I look forward to seeing them all! He's only been posting for a week and there are already some classics on there.
I'm not sure if you need to have a tumblr account to view the page but it's worth making one if porn for the early days of the internet is your thing!